Review: Pilgrimage (2017) – A Captivating Medieval Thriller Rooted in Faith and Brutality

Pilgrimage (2017): A Gripping Medieval Tale of Faith and Survival

“Pilgrimage,” directed by Brendan Muldowney, stands as a testament to the notion that a compelling story doesn’t require an extravagant budget. With a modest budget of just over $5 million, this 2017 medieval thriller delivers an engrossing narrative set in the 13th century, weaving together elements of faith, brutality, and survival.

The film unfolds in the Crusade-era, a period marked by volatility and hostility. It introduces us to a small group of monks residing on Ireland’s western coast, who are tasked with a perilous mission. Brother Geraldus (Stanley Weber), acting on the Pope’s orders, arrives to retrieve a sacred relic safeguarded by the monks and transport it back to Rome. This quest becomes the film’s central focus, echoing the adventurous spirit of Peter Jackson’s “The Fellowship of the Ring.”

Among the monks chosen for this mission are the young novice Brother Diarmuid (Tom Holland), the wise Brother Ciaran (John Lynch), and a mysterious mute (Jon Bernthal) who has loyally served the monastery. Their journey is fraught with danger as they traverse lands rife with factions vying for control. One such faction is led by Sir Raymond (Richard Armitage), a soldier devoted to his king, who reluctantly agrees to help escort the monks and the relic.

“Pilgrimage” transcends the typical quest narrative by delving into the spiritual and physical trials faced by its characters. Writer Jamie Hannigan crafts a story that explores the complexities of faith—whether in God, Rome, or earthly rulers—against the backdrop of a brutal and unforgiving world. The film adeptly juxtaposes the natural with the supernatural, divine providence with sheer chance, and the pious with the militant.

The visual storytelling, led by cinematographer Tom Comerford, enhances the film’s gripping atmosphere. From ominous, cloud-filled skies to stunning yet treacherous landscapes, the cinematography immerses viewers in the harsh reality of the medieval world. The bursts of violence, starkly contrasting with the monks’ pursuit of peace, underscore the brutal realities outside their cloistered existence.

The cast delivers stellar performances, with Tom Holland anchoring the narrative as Brother Diarmuid, showcasing his range as a young actor. Stanley Weber, Richard Armitage, and John Lynch also shine in their respective roles. However, it is Jon Bernthal who truly captivates with his portrayal of the mute. His silent yet powerful performance, marked by a vow of silence during preparation, adds depth and intensity to the character.

Despite its limited budget and a tight 30-day shooting schedule, “Pilgrimage” excels as both an action-packed medieval thriller and a profound exploration of faith. The film’s ability to balance intense action with deeper philosophical questions makes it a standout in its genre. It engages viewers from start to finish, offering a thought-provoking experience that warrants multiple viewings.

Hits: 35